Shai Gilgeous-Alexander vs Tyrese Maxey
Comparison based on 2025-26 results · Points scoring: PTS + 1.2×REB + 1.5×AST + 3×STL + 3×BLK − TO · the verdict also weighs 2026-27 projections, availability and ADP
Fantasy pts / game
50.648.8
50.6Fantasy pts / game48.8
Points
31.128.3
31.1Points28.3
Rebounds
4.34.1
4.3Rebounds4.1
Assists
6.66.6
6.6Assists6.6
Minutes
33.238.0
33.2Minutes38.0
Games played
6870
68Games played70
Floor (p10)
38.628.3
38.6Floor (p10)28.3
Ceiling (p90)
64.562.8
64.5Ceiling (p90)62.8
Consistency %
9485
94Consistency %85
Proj pts/game (2026-27)
48.544.8
48.5Proj pts/game (2026-27)44.8
Proj games (2026-27)
7276
72Proj games (2026-27)76
ADP (lower = pricier)
3.216.3
3.2ADP (lower = pricier)16.3
9-Cat rank (2025-26)
#3#5
#39-Cat rank (2025-26)#5
8-Cat rank (2025-26)
#3#6
#38-Cat rank (2025-26)#6
POINTS PICKShai Gilgeous-Alexander
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander holds the 2025-26 edge: 1.8 fantasy points per game, finishing #4 overall vs #6. The 2026-27 projection agrees: 48.5 vs 44.8 points per game. That said, Maxey goes 13 picks later by ADP (16.3 vs 3.2), so he is the cheaper route. Shai Gilgeous-Alexander remains the preferred points-league pick.
POINTS PICK Gilgeous-Alexander9-CAT PICK Gilgeous-Alexander8-CAT PICK Gilgeous-AlexanderCategory rankings
Based on 2025-26 results plus 2026-27 projections and live ADP · Computed by HoopSplit from official box scores — not an opinion poll.
Game-by-game form · 2025-26BOTH CHARTS SHARE ONE SCALE
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander — last 12 gamesLAST 5 VS AVG -6.0
Tyrese Maxey — last 12 gamesLAST 5 VS AVG -12.0